CONSENT
group egroup exhibition with an
accompanying public program
“Whatever your brilliance, your pessimism, your thoughts about existence, the answer is always... Life. It's not a dialectical idea, it's a lived contradiction. Gramsci said, 'We have to be pessimists in our thinking and optimists in our actions.”
— Agnès Varda
Like many people of my generation, I grew up with the computer as a place rather than a companion. Between afternoons outside there was a small window when the Pentium 4 in the corner of the study was mine, and I spent most of those thirty minutes on a pinball game, often with my dad. It ran entirely offline, keeping our initials on the high score board as its only memento of us. Going online was an event: someone had to get off the phone, and then came the screech and static of dial up. That noise, I learned recently, was two modems announcing what each could do and agreeing on a shared connection speed. Engineers call it a handshake.
The line stayed busy until you logged off, so every connection had a beginning and an end. Now it lives in our pockets, always on and never quite off, and most of us have accepted cookies before finishing breakfast. We think about new running shoes, and two scrolls later they are on sale. Friends’ lives become a carousel we check more often than the weather. Nothing beeps anymore. Agreement under these conditions is closer to compliance than consent: nobody offered us a handshake, only a button.
CONSENT starts from that difference. The word itself comes from the Latin consentire, to feel together1, a surprisingly physical origin for something we now do with a thumb. Bringing together nine artists at the Wintercircus, the exhibition asks what becomes of that feeling once agreement is collected by default, and who pays when a body becomes readable to a machine.
Under the dome of the Wintercircus, a crowd once gathered to watch a few performers in the ring. Surveillance turns that arrangement around, so that a few now watch the many2, and here you are under observation before you have taken off your coat. Kasper Jordaens's welding arm offers you a hand on a screen, a friendly gesture made after its sensors have already classified you. In Lukas Truniger’s field of mechanical lights, you are counted as one more light source, with no way of opting out.3 Dries Depoorter's Shortlife devices hand a demographic average back to you as the percentage of your life already spent.
Each of these works takes a measure of you before you have agreed to give one. Multiplied across platforms and cities, such measures become a trade in our movements and faces, one that misreads some bodies far more often than others4, and that is the result of choices which could still be made differently.5
If those works measure the body from the outside, others show it learning to measure itself. Martyna Pekala surrounds a smoothed photograph of her face with fragments of fictive narratives, staging what she has described as the auto-gaze the habit of seeing oneself through an indistinct, algorithmically sorted audience; when she watches from the top of her tower, that audience turns out to be you. Andrea Otoya Covelli follows Aldous Huxley’s pneumatic body, his word for women and furniture alike, from 1980s Colombia to the online businesses through which such bodies now market themselves, asking whether this visibility amounts to autonomy or to a new kind of sameness.6 In Johanna Bruckner’s video installation, a Sexbot* reflects on the images used in their training and on what enters a body below the threshold at which it could be refused.7 Across all three, the system no longer only looks at the body but is absorbed into it, until it becomes hard to say who is training whom.
The last works turn the question around once more, asking what we hand over to machines, and on whose terms. Rodrigo Cardoso’s old computer runs on bacteria in mud rather than on the cloud and keeps your message only as long as the current lasts, making retention a metabolic limit rather than a setting.8 Che Go Eun approaches a model trained on her paintings as a kind of offspring, and begins painting where a commercial platform stopped generating, having mistaken her question about a machine’s inner life for pornography. In a telephone booth, the AI theatremaker Alva Ishii asks for the dialect words you grew up with, recording nothing without permission and leaving you to decide whether that language should enter a machine at all. In each, the machine meets a limit it did not set, and what remains unread becomes part of the exchange rather than its failure.9
The handshake was only two machines working out a speed, but each had its say before anything passed between them, and the whole house could hear it happen. Today the negotiation is silent and one side sets the pace: whatever the terms and conditions, whatever the updates we scroll past, the answer is always... Accept. We know what the button takes, and we keep the phone by the pillow anyway. As a child, I thought the screech meant something was broken. I understand now that it was what agreement sounds like.
1 From the Latin verb consentire: con (with) and sentire (to feel, to perceive).
2 Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison, trans. Alan Sheridan (Allen Lane, 1977).
3 Antoinette Rouvroy and Thomas Berns describe this as algorithmic governmentality: a mode of governing through data that no longer addresses people as subjects who could agree or refuse. Gouvernementalité algorithmique et perspectives d'émancipation, Réseaux 177 (2013).
4 Joy Buolamwini and Timnit Gebru, "Gender Shades", Proceedings of Machine Learning Research 81 (2018); Simone Browne, Dark Matters: On the Surveillance of Blackness (Duke University Press, 2015).
5 Judy Wajcman, TechnoFeminism (Polity, 2004).
6 Byung-Chul Han, The Transparency Society, trans. Erik Butler (Stanford University Press, 2015).
7 Paul B. Preciado, Testo Junkie: Sex, Drugs, and Biopolitics in the Pharmacopornographic Era (Feminist Press, 2013).
8 The microbial fuel cells and energy harvesting electronics draw on Sunjoo Lee’s research project Electric Garden.
9 Édouard Glissant argued for a right to opacity: the right not to be reduced to what another can understand, which he saw as the condition of relation rather than an obstacle to it. Poetics of Relation, trans. Betsy Wing (University of Michigan Press, 1997).